Home World News Chief Justice considers appointing ex-Irish judges to Dubai Commercial Court - The...

Chief Justice considers appointing ex-Irish judges to Dubai Commercial Court – The Irish Times FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates,

The Chief Justice of the High Court said criticism surrounding the appointment of two retired senior Irish judges to the Dubai International Financial Center (DIFC) court was “ill-informed” and “a bit unfair”.

The controversy, which resulted in former Chief Justice Frank Clarke and former High Court President Peter Kelly resigning from the DIFC Court was a “terrible thing” to happen to both judges after their “incredible public service” to the state, Justice David said. Barniville.

Both resigned less than a week after being appointed in late July amid concerns, including from Labor Party chairwoman Ivana Bacíková, about the poor human rights record of the Dubai administration.

In a wide-ranging interview with The Irish Times, the newly appointed Chief Justice addressed the dispute, among many other issues.

He “strongly supports” the reversal of cuts to legal aid fees, still at 2002 levels, and hopes the government will approve 20 extra High Court judges as it seeks to clear backlogs.

It also favors more physical and hybrid (combined physical and remote) hearings when the new legal term opens next month.

In the first public comment by a senior judge here on the DIFC appointment dispute, Mr Justice Barniville said Mr Clarke and Mr Kelly were private citizens who had to retire as judges here when they reached the age of 70.

Their “excellent international reputation” was the reason they were asked to be appointed to the DIFC court, he said. “A lot of the criticism of this court has been ill-informed and I think a little bit unfair.”

Retired common law judges sit in international commercial courts around the world, including the Gulf states, he said. These courts, including the DIFC, have an “outstanding reputation” internationally and are members of the Permanent Forum of International Commercial Courts, along with major international commercial courts including Ireland, the US and the UK.

International reputation

An Irish judge had never before been appointed to either of these courts and the appointment to the DIFC court was a “great honour” to the international reputation of the two retired judges.

Some critics’ comparisons between the LIV golf tour in Saudi Arabia and the DIFC courts were “completely incorrect”.

The DIFC is separate from Dubai’s domestic courts – which operate under Sharia law – and is seen as playing a very important role in enforcing and maintaining the rule of law in commercial disputes in that jurisdiction, he said.

“I don’t think the comparison was fair, but I fully understand why both Peter Kelly and Frank Clarke, in the face of the kind of public criticism that came out at the time, decided they didn’t want to stay on the court. They didn’t need that kind of trouble. I think for people who have given such good service to the state over the years, it was a terrible shame and terrible for them.

“I’m very happy to say that I think very, very highly of them both and I don’t think any less of them as a result. I understand why they resigned, but I think a lot of critics didn’t really understand what the issue was.

Asked about human rights, he said: “You don’t always have to approve of the regime to function as part of it.” Many Irish firms do business in Dubai and other Gulf countries, he said. There is a lot of government people-to-people contact in Dubai and it is a “hugely important market for Ireland”.



Most Popular

“No more G23 camp, all Congress leaders united to fight against BJP, RSS”: Mallikarjun Kharge FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, “All leaders (of G23) want to stay together and work together to fight BJP-RSS. That is why they are supporting...

Cannabis plants at Farnworth property destroyed by police FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, Police in Farnworth discovered over 100 cannabis plants inside a property on Campbell...

Glasgow’s Pollok Country Park is moving to MORE limited edition cars FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, Southside park to build barriers to stop people from driving through major plan to restrict cars. ...

Windy, cooler conditions to close the weekend – NECN FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, A cool and blustery afternoon with wind chills in the 50s to 40s and an even colder night ahead. Freeze advisories and...

Draconid Meteor Showers 2022: When They Peak and How to Watch Them FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, Of course, these are not actually stars, but debris from comet 21P/Giacobini-Zinner, which orbits the Sun.Earth passes through these debris every...

power cut india, no need for inverter, these are the best rechargeable led bulb in a budget price range check features FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, New Delhi: Best Rechargeable LED Bulbs: These days there are many essential and daily useful products available on e-commerce platforms. ...

Protesters pour ‘human excrement’ on Sir Captain Tom Moore’s memorial. FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, A climate campaigner poured what she claimed was "human excrement" on a memorial to late war veteran Sir Captain Tom Moore...

Health Minister Thérèse Coffey has ignored advice to restock monkeypox vaccine FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, The Terrence Higgins Trust said Thérèse Coffey's decision not to give more monkeypox vaccines "would be worrying and short-sighted". (Getty) ...

Brexiteer Steve Baker apologizes for ‘savage’ anti-EU stance FindSexyJobs

FSJ News Updates, A former pro-Brexit Northern Ireland minister has apologized for his once "wild" stance...